Intellectuals vs. thought leaders

Good friend Praveen sent me the piece by David Brooks in NYT on intellectuals and thought leaders.  I enjoyed reading it.

I loved this quote:

“It will be necessary to resist the tendency to render easy that which cannot become easy without being distorted.”

It is attributed to Gramsci.

Applies in many different contexts – from parenting to public policy! But, given recent policy initiatives of the government in India, easy to think of public policy applications.

Essentially, Mr. Brooks argues that the pendulum had swung too far towards thought leaders away from intellectuals. That needs correction, in his view.

The world needs intellectuals too, even if they are wrong. In other words, one needs long-term abstract thinkers who gaze into the sky for an infinitely long period as much as one needs TED talkers and thinkers.

Somewhat analogously, one needs both of

  • op.-ed. writers and long-form writers.
  • short essays and books.
  • poetry and prose